News Reel #2: Affirmative Action Wording
March 8th, 2010 | Published in From DebateChamps
DebateChamps is proud to support the NFL and Rupe Scholars with sample research. If you like what you see, feel free to check out our website. With 12 forensics vendors in one store, we’re the one stop speech and debate shop.
Wording Affirmative Action
The words we use in the Affirmative Action debate can be highlight charged emotionally. Debaters should be carefully to use emotionally-charged language carefully. Those claiming Affirmative Action is just may want to opt for different terms such as Employment Equity and Education Equity. Aside from having snappy alliteration (something I am personally always a fan of in PF debate), the terms are also less likely to have a previous opinion already attached to them. PF judges are likely to already have an opinion about affirmative action. Limiting the outside influence by carefully wording our arguments is absolutely necessary.
Call it Employment Equity, not Affirmative Action
http://www.newsweek.com/id/233824
- The term, Affirmative Action, has a negative association attached to it
- Calling Affirmative Action opportunities Employment Equity may be more beneficial
- Article provides good background on Affirmative Action and its original implementation
- Diverse student bodies are good
Wording of Affirmative Action Can Change Public View
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/02/28/weekinreview/28sussman.html
- The wording changes the American public’s view substantially
- “preferences to minorities” results in a majority opposition
- Proposals aimed at making up for pass discrimination show half in favor
Affirmative action is an obligation.
http://www.deseretnews.com/article/700010658/Affirmative-action-still-needed-in-Utah.html
- Affirmative action needed to remedy “subjugation of racial and ethnic minorities and of women”
- Needed to combat exclusion for multiple minorities—not just African Americans
- Necessary for a balanced representation of diversity
DebateChamps is the high school forensics superstore. As a member of the SpeechGeek family of forensics website and resources, DebateChamps provides a wide selection of speech and debate products in one place. With twelve vendors offering products to meet your needs in every major forensics event, DebateChamps is your one stop speech and debate shop. More information online at http://www.debatechamps.com.




